Choosing between wood and vinyl fencing? Both are popular choices for privacy fences, but they differ significantly in cost, maintenance, and longevity. Here's a complete comparison.
Cost Comparison
Wood (pine): $17–$45 per linear foot installed. A 150 ft fence costs $2,550–$6,750.
Vinyl: $25–$60 per linear foot installed. A 150 ft fence costs $3,750–$9,000.
Wood wins on upfront cost — it's 30–50% cheaper. But the story changes when you factor in maintenance.
Maintenance
Wood requires staining or sealing every 2–3 years ($1.50–$4/ft) and occasional board replacement. Over 20 years, maintenance costs add $2,000–$5,000.
Vinyl needs zero maintenance — just occasional hosing off. No painting, staining, or sealing ever.
Durability
Wood (pine): 10–15 years. Wood (cedar): 15–25 years.
Vinyl: 20–30 years with most manufacturers offering a lifetime warranty.
Appearance
Wood offers a natural, classic look that many homeowners prefer. It can be painted or stained any color. However, it grays and weathers over time without maintenance.
Vinyl maintains its appearance for decades but comes in limited colors (mainly white, tan, and gray). Some people find it looks "plastic."
20-Year Total Cost
For a 150 ft fence:
- Wood (pine): $6,750 initial + $3,500 maintenance + $6,750 replacement at year 12 = ~$17,000
- Vinyl: $9,000 initial + $0 maintenance = $9,000
Vinyl is cheaper over 20 years despite higher upfront cost.
Verdict
Choose wood if: You want the cheapest upfront option, prefer a natural look, or plan to sell the house within 5 years.
Choose vinyl if: You want zero maintenance, plan to stay long-term, or live in a humid/wet climate where wood rots faster.
Use our fence cost calculator to compare costs for your specific project.